A law firm I work with made 15,000 euros in its best months. A few months later: zero.
Not a drop. Zero.
When that happens, you look for a culprit. We looked at three. The first two were innocent. The third one, almost nobody in France is talking about yet.
First suspect: us
We’re partners in this firm. Its business is our responsibility. So the first question is the most uncomfortable one: did we do a bad job?
We checked. Over the same period, other firms we work with are doing really well. It wasn’t about getting clients. Demand itself had changed.
Second suspect: the simple stuff
The explanation you hear everywhere: AI takes the simple stuff, the standard letters and filings, and judgment stays with lawyers. So this firm must have been doing too much simple stuff.
Except it was doing roughly half routine work, half complex cases. If only the simple stuff had gone, it would still have half its revenue. It has nothing left.
So that’s not it either. Something else went with it.
The real culprit
The real culprit is a habit. People got used to asking ChatGPT or Claude about everything. Law is no exception.
But why even the complex cases? Here’s what I think. A lawyer has to master every situation in his field, because he has lots of clients with lots of different cases. The client only needs to master one situation: his own. With ChatGPT next to him, he can dig into his case for hours, for free. He doesn’t need to become a lawyer. Just the best expert on his own case.
So even part of the judgment gets eaten.
I’m not the only one seeing it
Public numbers point the same way. In France’s administrative courts, where you often don’t need a lawyer, new cases went from 257,000 in 2023 to 370,000 over the last twelve months, according to the Conseil d’État, France’s highest administrative court. The French legal press calls it a “litigation tsunami,” likely fueled by AI. Nobody has measured exactly how much of it is AI yet. But the Conseil d’État just put six million euros into equipping its judges… with AI tools.
What we don’t know yet
Do these people win? Honestly, we don’t know. We’ll find out later, once we have some distance on the rulings. Some of them crash: in August, a French administrative court fined a taxpayer 500 euros for an abusive appeal she had drafted with AI.
But they still go for it. And while we wait to find out, lawyers who studied for years, who have a family, a life, watch their new cases disappear. In a few months. We’re talking months now, not years.
What protects you
The winners exist: we see them, in the same numbers. From what I see, what protects them comes down to one question: is the stake heavy enough in the client’s life that he refuses to take the risk of doing it alone? Even if he could.
When the stake touches what matters most in someone’s life, nobody plays around with a chatbot. And clients who can afford it would rather delegate than spend their evenings on it.
What you do with this
If you’re a lawyer, try a simple exercise. Go back through your cases from the last six months. For each one, ask yourself: could this client, and more importantly would this client, have done it alone with ChatGPT? Every yes is revenue at risk. Not in five years. In the next few months. And for every no, ask yourself why: that’s where your real value is.
If you’re a builder or an investor, look at what’s happening. A huge number of people are starting to handle their legal matters themselves. They still need help. Just not necessarily a lawyer the way it used to work.
It has already started. By the time everyone talks about it, it’ll be too late to find out.